Fee simple vs leasehold Hawaii condos for buyers

If you have been looking at condos for sale in Hawaiʻi, you have probably noticed two terms that can make a significant difference in the price: fee simple and leasehold. Two condos in the same neighborhood can look remarkably similar online, yet one may be priced substantially lower than the other. In many cases, the difference comes down to who owns the underlying land and the type of interest being sold.

This distinction is particularly important in Hawaiʻi, where leasehold ownership remains part of the residential real estate market. A leasehold condo is not simply a less expensive version of a fee-simple condo. You are purchasing a different type of ownership interest, with its own lease terms, financial considerations and potential resale implications. That does not automatically make leasehold a bad choice, but it does mean you need to understand exactly what you are purchasing before comparing the price with a fee-simple property.

What is the difference between fee simple and leasehold?

With a fee-simple property, you own your condominium interest as well as the underlying land interest associated with the property. There is no ground lease with a predetermined expiration date, although you are still subject to the condominium's declaration, bylaws, association rules, zoning and other applicable laws.

With a leasehold condo, the situation is different. You own an interest in the condominium and the rights granted to you under the lease, but another party owns the underlying land. You pay lease rent to the landowner for the right to use that land for the period specified in the lease. The Hawaiʻi Department of Commerce and Consumer Affairs describes leasehold ownership as the right to occupy and use the apartment for the term of the lease rather than outright ownership of the underlying land.

That difference is fundamental because it affects more than the purchase price. The remaining lease term, lease rent, renegotiation provisions, financing requirements and what happens when the lease expires can all influence whether a particular leasehold condo makes sense for you.

Why are leasehold condos less expensive?

The lower purchase price is usually the first thing that attracts buyers to a leasehold property. Because you are not purchasing the underlying land, the initial cost can be considerably lower than a comparable fee-simple property. The Hawaiʻi Housing Finance and Development Corporation similarly explains that separating the cost of the land from the improvements can reduce the initial purchase price of a leasehold property.

That price difference can be substantial enough to make a building or neighborhood accessible to a buyer who might otherwise be priced out. However, I would caution against looking at the purchase price alone. A $600,000 leasehold condo and a $600,000 fee-simple condo do not necessarily represent the same financial proposition because the leasehold owner may also have an ongoing lease-rent obligation and a defined lease term to consider.

In other words, the lower price is not necessarily a discount on an identical product. You are purchasing a different ownership structure, and the value of that structure depends heavily on the terms of the individual lease.

What is lease rent?

Lease rent is the payment made to the landowner for the use of the underlying land. It is separate from your mortgage, property taxes, insurance and condominium maintenance fees, so a buyer needs to understand the total monthly cost rather than looking only at the HOA or maintenance fee shown in a listing.

The way lease rent changes over time is especially important. Some leases establish a particular rent for a defined period and then provide for renegotiation at specified dates. Depending on the lease terms, the resulting rent can increase significantly. Hawaiʻi DCCA specifically advises prospective buyers to understand how lease rent is determined and notes that renegotiated rents may be substantially higher than the original amount.

For that reason, I would want to know not only what the lease rent is today, but also when it can change, how the new amount will be determined and what the lease says about future renegotiations. Those details can make a meaningful difference when comparing a leasehold condo with a fee-simple alternative.

What happens when a lease expires?

This is one of the most important questions to answer before purchasing a leasehold condo.

A lease has a defined term, and the rights granted under that lease can end when the term expires. What happens at that point depends on the actual lease documents. Some properties may have provisions for extension or conversion, while other leases contain surrender provisions that can require the apartment and improvements to be returned to the lessor at the end of the lease. Hawaiʻi DCCA's consumer guidance specifically warns that some leasehold agreements contain surrender clauses under which the apartment, improvements and land may revert to the lessor without compensation.

That does not mean every leasehold property will have the same outcome, which is exactly why the individual lease matters. Before purchasing, I would want to know the expiration date, whether there is an extension option, whether fee conversion is possible, how surrender is handled and whether there have been previous amendments to the lease.

The remaining term also becomes increasingly important as you get closer to expiration. A buyer planning to own a property for five years may evaluate a particular lease very differently from someone hoping to keep the property for several decades, and a future buyer will make the same calculation when you eventually sell.

Does the lease expiration affect resale value?

It can. A leasehold property may have a narrower pool of potential buyers depending on the remaining lease term and the terms of the lease. Financing can become more complicated as the lease gets shorter, and buyers may be less willing to purchase a property if they are uncertain about future lease rent or what will happen at expiration.

This is one reason I would not compare leasehold and fee-simple condos strictly on price per square foot. A leasehold condo may look like an exceptional bargain on paper, but the remaining lease term, lease rent and future obligations need to be incorporated into the analysis.

At the same time, I would not assume that every leasehold condo is difficult to resell. Properties with attractive locations, desirable floor plans, favorable lease terms and a long remaining lease can still appeal to buyers. The important question is whether the ownership structure makes sense for the particular buyer and their expected holding period.

Can you finance a leasehold condo?

Yes, but financing a leasehold property can involve additional requirements that do not apply to a typical fee-simple condominium. Fannie Mae's current Selling Guide has specific requirements for mortgages secured by leasehold interests, including requirements relating to the leasehold estate, the mortgage lien and the remaining term of the lease.

The remaining lease term is particularly relevant because lenders need to be comfortable that the lease will remain in effect for an appropriate period relative to the mortgage. This means buyers should speak with their lender early rather than assuming that financing a leasehold property will work exactly the same way as financing a fee-simple condo.

I would especially recommend doing this before getting emotionally attached to a particular property. The fact that a leasehold condo is technically financeable does not necessarily mean that every lender will offer the same terms, loan amount or interest rate for that property.

What about fee conversion?

Some leasehold buildings have the potential to convert from leasehold to fee simple, but this should never be assumed simply because another building has gone through a conversion.

A fee conversion generally involves the owner of the leased-fee interest offering the condominium owners the opportunity to purchase the underlying land interest. If the conversion takes place, the owner's interest becomes fee simple rather than leasehold. The terms and cost of that conversion are critical, however, and the fact that a conversion is possible does not necessarily mean that it will happen or that it will be affordable.

Hawaiʻi DCCA recommends that prospective buyers investigate whether a fee conversion is planned or available and understand the terms of the offer before making assumptions about the property's future ownership structure.

Is leasehold always a bad investment?

No, and I think it is important to be more nuanced than that. There are situations where a leasehold condo can make sense. A buyer may want to be in a particular building or location that would otherwise be outside their budget, or they may have a defined time horizon that makes the remaining lease term appropriate for their plans. If the purchase price is substantially lower and the lease terms are favorable, the overall economics can work.

The mistake is treating the lower purchase price as if there is no tradeoff. The buyer is accepting a different ownership structure in exchange for that lower initial cost, so the question becomes whether the savings justify the lease terms and the potential limitations later.

For some buyers, the answer may be yes. For others, particularly someone looking for a long-term hold with maximum flexibility and straightforward resale, fee simple may be the better fit.

What should you look at before buying a leasehold condo?

If I were evaluating a leasehold property for a buyer, I would want to understand the entire lease, not just the purchase price and current lease rent shown in the MLS. The first things I would look at are the lease expiration date, current lease rent, future renegotiation dates, the method used to calculate future rent, any extension or conversion provisions, surrender requirements and the property's financing considerations.

I would also look at the condominium documents and the history of the property. Has the lease previously been amended? Has the building offered a fee conversion? Are there upcoming renegotiation dates? How have similar units performed in the resale market? These questions can provide much more useful information than simply comparing the asking price with neighboring fee-simple condos.

Because the lease is a legal document, buyers should have their attorney review provisions they do not understand rather than relying on a general explanation of leasehold ownership.

Fee simple vs. leasehold at a glance

Which is better for a condo buyer?

For buyers looking for a long-term condominium purchase, fee simple is generally the simpler ownership structure because you are purchasing the condominium interest and underlying land interest without an expiring ground lease.

But I would not automatically dismiss a leasehold property. The right comparison is not simply “fee simple is better.” It is about understanding what you are paying for, what your ongoing costs will be, how long you expect to own the property and what options you will have when you eventually want to sell.

For example, a buyer who can purchase a desirable leasehold condo for substantially less than the equivalent fee-simple residence may decide that the tradeoff makes sense. Another buyer may prefer to pay more upfront for fee simple because they want maximum flexibility and a simpler long-term ownership structure.

Both decisions can be rational. They simply reflect different priorities and risk tolerances.

The bottom line

Leasehold is one of the Hawaiʻi real estate concepts that can seem confusing when you first start looking at condos, particularly when you see two properties that appear comparable but have very different asking prices. Once you understand that the difference is fundamentally about ownership of the underlying land, the pricing begins to make more sense.

The important thing is to look beyond the headline price. If you are considering a leasehold condo, understand the remaining lease term, current and future lease rent, renegotiation provisions, expiration and surrender clauses, potential fee conversion and financing requirements before deciding whether the property represents good value.

For fee-simple condos, the analysis is generally more straightforward, but the building and individual residence still matter enormously. For leasehold properties, the lease itself becomes another major part of the due diligence.

When I help buyers compare condos in Hawaiʻi, I think about the purchase as more than finding the right unit. The building, ownership structure, location, views, maintenance costs, future development and long-term plans all need to make sense together.

If you are looking at condos in Hawaiʻi and are unsure whether fee simple or leasehold makes more sense for you, I can help you compare the ownership structure, building, individual residence and long-term considerations before you decide which properties are worth pursuing.

LinkedIn Instagram

Your Top Hawaiʻi Luxury Condo Specialist

Lucy Heath

Lucy Heath is a Real Estate Advisor at Compass and the founder of Luxury Condos Hawaiʻi, recognized for her expertise in refined condominium living in Kakaʻako and Ala Moana. She has lived in Ward Village for over six years, witnessing its transformation from the earliest stages of development into one of Honolulu's most sought-after neighborhoods.

Get in Touch